State Auditor General Eugene DePasquale’s report on city school finances was largely laudatory, but it also raised a troubling question about how the district has been making financial projections.
Yes, the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration has done an admirable job of living within its means, reducing per-pupil spending, keeping a lid on the property tax rate and paying down its debt. And having money left over at the end of each of the past four years, as the audit showed, was a good thing.
But even Mr. DePasquale, while generous in his praise of the district’s sound spending, raised a red flag because it seems to have been saving too much. By last year, the district had built up a surplus of $129 million, the largest in the state.
In an audit released last week, Mr. DePasquale said “a generous fund balance is a necessary component of a fiscally healthy school district,” but he added that the recommended level is 10 percent of its general fund.
Pittsburgh’s savings has been much higher in three of the last four years — 13.2 percent in 2011, 27.9 percent in 2013 and 13.6 percent in 2014. Although 2012 was under the target, 8.4 percent signified a surplus nonetheless, and all of those figures were a far cry from the zero registered in 2010.
The hefty surpluses don’t compute with the dire warnings the district has issued consistently in recent years, first projecting in 2012 that it would run out of money by 2015. Each subsequent year, the dead-end date was moved, but city taxpayers have been living with the impression that the situation remained dire.
The district attributed its success to higher tax revenue than anticipated and cost containment efforts. Good management is one explanation, but the repeated nature of the generous surpluses raises the question of why the projections were so far off.
The lessons from Mr. DePasquale’s audit are twofold: Keep doing what you’ve been doing with expenses, but do a better job of preparing realistic spending plans. Otherwise, there is the danger of becoming the boy who cried wolf, leaving taxpayers deaf to real concerns that may arise in the future.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.