The dispute over development of the site where the Civic Arena sat just won’t end.

The contentious process that started eight years ago when the Pittsburgh Penguins won the rights to lead the effort appeared to be resolved in September 2014 with a deal signed by the team, elected city and county officials and the leader of the Hill Community Development Corp.

Then, not two months later, the CDC and Pittsburgh City Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle tried to change the terms related to how much housing in the plan should be set aside for lower-income families. This month, more than a year after what had seemed to be a done deal, a different community group lodged a new complaint. The Hill District Consensus Group’s filing with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development says the plan will result in the disproportionate exclusion of black residents. It says the income cap of 80 percent of the area’s median income set for most units is too high, and that it should be 50 percent. To do otherwise, the group says, would be discriminatory.

The matter now rests with HUD, although the group’s attorney says he’s hoping for a settlement.

Advertise with us

Reaching a meeting of the minds so far has proved to be impossible, at least in part because various Hill District community groups don’t agree on what they want to see happen on the parcel. At every turn, someone has challenged some part of the deal, setting up a moving target that has become impossible for elected officials and the Pittsburgh Penguins to hit.

The continuing arguments over the Penguins’ plans are frustrating, and they could be very detrimental if the project is stalled or stopped as a result.

Pittsburgh has a marvelous opportunity to hook the 28-acre property on the cusp of Downtown into the prosperity of the city’s core. Or it can be frittered away with squabbling and an ever-evolving list of untenable demands.

Meet the Editorial Board.