Country music star Kenny Chesney riled up Pittsburghers more than once when his fans left parts of the North Shore and Downtown trashed after his sold-out performances. Turns out he left the city’s bank account a bit short, too.

Mr. Chesney’s is just one of the acts that somehow managed to pay far less than the ticket sales would suggest was due in the form of a usage fee assessed against nonresidents when they perform in publicly owned venues. Pittsburgh Controller Michael Lamb found that out in an audit of the direct revenue the city gets from Heinz Field, PNC Park and Consol Energy Center.

Not to miss the big picture here, the audit determined that the Pittsburgh Sports & Exhibition Authority and the city Stadium Authority — the agencies that own the three facilities — brought in significant dollars: $107.2 million in taxes and fees from 2009 through 2013. The figure included amusement, parking, income and real estate taxes, as well as the usage fee. The amusement tax, which is added to the cost of a ticket, was by far the biggest producer, bringing in $47.8 million. By contrast, the facility usage fee raised $17.8 million.

Performers and professional athletes who don’t live in Pittsburgh are supposed to pay 3 percent of whatever income they earn while they’re working here. But where Mr. Chesney paid $135 at Heinz Field in 2011, Taylor Swift paid $63,486. Disparities showed up at Consol, too — Paul McCartney paid $75,000 and $57,329 for two shows that opened the arena, while Lady Gaga paid $22,571, the Eagles $11,273 and Justin Bieber $16,333. Some performers paid nothing, including Rod Stewart, Stevie Nicks and Barry Manilow.

Advertise with us

Payments due from athletes have not proved to be as unpredictable, so it’s clear the music acts are using different methods to compute their share. Mr. Lamb is correct to point out the unfairness of that, even if it’s not a whole lot of money overall.

Fortunately, the city’s law and finance departments are at work on a way to close the loophole so the city collects what’s due from performers who can well afford to pay their share.

Meet the Editorial Board.