North America used to be home to up to 60 million bison. Now, 5,000 is said to be too many within the borders of Yellowstone National Park, which proposes to kill a thousand of the iconic creatures this winter.

The practice of culling the animals is not new, but this is the first time Yellowstone has proposed to primarily kill female bison and their calves. This should give pause to even those who believe the herd has grown unmanageably large. If burgeoning bison are a problem, other solutions must be found.

Nearly 4 million people visit Yellowstone each year, and many come to see the wild bison which have roamed there since prehistoric times. Hunting nearly caused the animals’ extinction; only two dozen remained in Yellowstone in 1902. The numbers increased with federal protection and the importation of animals from other areas for breeding.

Although most of the park is in Wyoming, it extends to Montana and Idaho, and Montana has been vehement in its desire to keep bison away, even sending sharpshooters to Yellowstone’s boundaries in the late 1990s. An agreement Montana struck with the federal government in 2000 requires that bison be killed each year to keep their numbers down. Some are hunted by Indian tribes; others are simply slaughtered or rounded up and used for research.

Advertise with us

Tough problems require hard solutions, and bison is, of course, served in some restaurants and touted as a healthful alternative to beef. But what Americans tolerate on a feedlot, they will not stomach in their federal parks, where majestic wild animals like bison should be protected. The plan to slaughter calves and mothers must be shelved and humane options explored.

Meet the Editorial Board.