The Pennsylvania House approved a bill Tuesday that would keep the names of police officers from the public while they’re being investigated for using force or firing their weapons in the line of duty. House Bill 1538 would allow for the release of the officer’s name, though, if and when criminal charges were pending.
This ill-conceived proposal denies the public its right to know the names of officers involved in fatal or near-fatal encounters with civilians. Sponsored by Rep. Martina White, R-Philadelphia, and passed on a lopsided 162-38 vote, it was overwhelmingly supported by law enforcement groups but bitterly opposed by civil liberties advocates.
Public skepticism about a police action is usually at its height right after a shooting, yet the bill removes the ability of citizens to ask legitimate questions about the officer involved until charges are brought. Because police are sanctioned to use violence and take a life when they deem it necessary, every police department has an interest to share as much information as possible with the public as soon as an incident occurs.
Another reason for disclosure is it removes the cloud of suspicion from other members of the police force, and it reduces distrust between police and the community they serve.
Lawmakers who backed the bill did so on the dubious premise that police officers and their families are in danger the moment their identities become known after a questionable shooting. No one offered evidence, however, that officers in such situations are commonly subject to threats and harassment, or worse.
Pennsylvanians don’t want to live in a society where police action, on behalf of the public, is beyond scrutiny. Let’s hope the Senate takes a more sober view of the measure and derails it. If not, it will be up to Gov. Tom Wolf to use his veto.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.