President Barack Obama began his visit to the Philippines Tuesday by announcing a gift of two U.S. ships to that country, as well as a $250 million increase in overall military aid to the region.

The message that Mr. Obama is sending is directed, first, at the smaller nations of East Asia that feel they need reinforcement in the face of increasing Chinese efforts to exercise its natural hegemony in the region. Chinese leader Xi Jinping is becoming steadily more energetic in seeking to reflect his country’s economic strength in greater political and military visibility in East Asia.  China’s creation of a growing number of artificial islands in the South China Sea, to formalize its claim on some of the largely underwater reefs there, is an obvious manifestation of that policy.

The Philippines, Malaysia, Vietnam and other nations dispute the Chinese claims and actively seek U.S. support for their interests.

Mr. Obama is trying to have it both ways. It is unrealistic for him not to act on the basis of China and the United States both being major world powers that need to cooperate in a wide range of areas. The United States would be deluding itself to pretend that U.S.-Philippine ties are more important than U.S.-Chinese relations. Even so, America has played a major role in East and Southeast Asia for many decades, in no small part through its naval dominance, and there is no reason to throw that card away.

Advertise with us

The gift of the two ships to the Philippines (one a Coast Guard cutter, the other a research vessel) can be criticized on two scores. First, the Manila government is still dragging its feet on giving the United States renewed access to what used to be its Subic Bay base. Second, the Coast Guard is already short of ships without giving one away and therefore inadequately prepared to pursue America’s interests in the Arctic as the ice melts and greater sea traffic results.

Does the United States really have two ships and $250 million to hand over to Asia? Just because Mr. Obama thinks so doesn’t mean he’s right.

Meet the Editorial Board.