While the budget framework worked out by the governor and legislative leaders contains a 21 percent sales tax increase (from 6 percent to 7.25 percent), it’s hard to fathom why the tentative plan doesn’t call for raising the cigarette tax.
Pennsylvania, after all, is hobbled by a $2 billion deficit, yet the $1.60-a-pack sin tax has been unchanged since 2009. Even worse, this is the only state that doesn’t tax cigars and other tobacco products.
Several officials close to the budget talks say some attention is now being given to new taxes on tobacco. Let’s hope they’re serious because the benefits are real.
A $1 hike in the cigarette tax, which Gov. Tom Wolf had proposed earlier, would generate an estimated $358 million a year. Pennsylvania’s tax is not excessive — it’s the same as the national average and lower than New York’s ($4.35) and Maryland’s ($2).
A higher tax would reduce tobacco consumption and the myriad health problems it generates. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that smoking is the nation’s leading cause of preventable death, taking 480,000 lives each year. Along the way, it runs up $170 billion in direct medical costs.
Since tobacco is a price-sensitive consumer product, raising the tax on cigarettes and slapping one on smokeless tobacco would discourage use by young people. And everyone knows the best way to quit smoking is never to start.
In September the CDC reported a 10 percent drop in cigarette smoking among adults compared with the prior year. In January-March of 2014, 16.8 percent of adults said they smoked. In the first quarter of this year, the portion was 15.2 percent. That’s progress, but it still leaves 42 million smokers, 18 years or older, including 2.2 million in Pennsylvania.
Until more of those smokers learn to quit, Mr. Wolf and the Legislature can get help balancing their budget from new tobacco taxes.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.