Shoot or don’t shoot. It’s the toughest call any police officer has to make, and it’s one that has to be made in an instant.

That’s why clear policies and comprehensive training for police are paramount, and why the situation in Pittsburgh is unconscionable.

This month, officers have fired into moving cars in two incidents — one last week in the crowded aftermath of a Penguins game when a sergeant shot at a car that had struck a detective near Consol Energy Center but kept moving, and the other on Oct. 10 when the target was a car that nearly hit another officer as it sped out of the parking lot of the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium.

In both cases, the circumstances were dangerous, and no one was injured as a result of officers shooting into moving vehicles. Nonetheless, the incidents exposed confusion in the city’s policy on pursuit tactics and its rules of when it’s appropriate for officers to fire.

Advertise with us

A 2011 policy says officers may shoot at moving vehicles if the occupants are using deadly force against police or anyone else, whether with a gun or other weapon and even if the vehicle itself is being operated in a way intended to hurt someone. That seems to be the policy that officers in the recent incidents followed.

But former police chief Nate Harper issued a different order in 2013. He said officers could not fire at moving vehicles unless shots had been fired from it, and that his order was to be incorporated into police policy. Harper is long gone, having been convicted of using public dollars for personal expenses, but the questions of why he proposed the change and whether it should be implemented persist.

There’s a big difference between the two rules, and officers should not be placed in a situation where they have questions of what is appropriate and permissible and what isn’t. Based on the information provided to the public so far, it’s not clear which policy is in effect and what officers have been advised. According to a spokeswoman for the bureau, Chief Cameron McLay and his command staff are expected to amend the policy soon, which suggests a lack of clarity inside the bureau, too.

The brass better not waste any time. Police officers need to know.

Meet the Editorial Board.