Typically an outpouring of sympathy and support occurs any time a helpless animal is injured or killed by a cruel human, but one form of assistance is lacking in Pennsylvania: tough penalties for the crimes.
For the third consecutive legislative session, state Rep. Dom Costa, a Stanton Heights Democrat, has introduced a measure that would ramp up the severity of punishment. The overwhelming number of first offenses for animal abuse under the state’s crimes code are considered a summary offense, much like a traffic ticket, subject to fines but rarely even a threat of jail time. House Bill 113 would change that.
Animal cruelty is broadly defined in the bill as when a person, whether the animal’s owner or not, beats, neglects, abandons or abuses it, depriving it of necessary food, water, shelter or veterinary care. The grade of the violation would increase from a summary offense to a third-degree misdemeanor, subject to higher fines and the possibility of incarceration for up to a year. Killing, maiming or poisoning a domestic animal would be a first-degree misdemeanor, an offense that can be subject to jail time of up to five years. Repeat offenses would be felonies under the law, carrying the threat of stiffer sentences. The bill also calls for harsh penalties for individuals who harm zoo animals.
In his sponsorship memorandum for the bill, Mr. Costa said the measure is necessary for the protection of animals, but he also points to studies linking animal cruelty and domestic violence, as well as other attacks on people. According to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, a study from 11 U.S. cities revealed that a history of pet abuse is one of four of the most significant indicators of who may become a domestic batterer, and another, in Texas, said that people who abuse pets are more dangerous and violent than those who do not. The ASPCA referenced another study that said children who were exposed to domestic violence were more likely to be cruel to animals.
State lawmakers have an opportunity to do more than wonder what they could have done to punish animal abusers and, it is hoped, to reduce the incidence of such violence. They have a chance to do something about it by passing House Bill 113.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.