This fall Allegheny County voters won’t have the same daunting task they did in the spring primary — winnowing a list of eight candidates for Common Pleas Court to a handful of nominees. When people go to the polls on Nov. 3, their charge will be to elect three judges from a field of four.
While the task may be easier, it will still require careful choosing.
With the courts and those who run them a mystery to many voters, it can be tempting to sit out judicial elections. But this race is important: Allegheny County Common Pleas Court is the level of justice closest to the public. Its judges handle the full range of civil and criminal cases. They also deal with divorces, child custody disputes, adoptions, abuse claims and estate battles.
Due to the option of candidates to cross-file in Pennsylvania for both parties’ nominations and based on the vote totals in the May primary, here are the four nominees and how they will appear on next month’s ballot: Jennifer Staley McCrady of Oakland and Daniel Regan of McCandless, who won both Democratic and Republican nominations; Hugh McGough of Shadyside, Democrat; and P.J. Murray of Upper St. Clair, Republican.
Mr. Regan, 40, is a partner with Caputo, Caputo & Regan, where he handles general litigation. The son of North Side magistrate Bernard “Baldy” Regan, he graduated from Cardozo Law School at Yeshiva University, then became a law clerk in state Superior Court. He worked for three years as an assistant district attorney in Allegheny County and from 2010 to 2014 as Pittsburgh’s solicitor under then-Mayor Luke Ravenstahl. In an interview with Post-Gazette editors, he said he was particularly proud of his work on a city task force to eradicate nuisance properties.
Notwithstanding his prior work, we found these three candidates had the temperament, broad-gauged experience and legal depth that better prepared them for the court:
• Ms. McCrady, 42, is the supervising attorney and program coordinator at a child advocacy program, KidsVoice (formerly Legal Aid for Children), which represents abused and neglected juveniles. She joined the nonprofit a decade and a half ago as an intern while she attended law school at Duquesne University. She filed the lawsuit that compelled the McKeesport Area School District to provide equal education opportunities for children living in the Auberle group home. She is also a national authority on how government and organizations can help teens who, because of age, are no longer eligible for foster care.
• Mr. McGough, 59, has been a magisterial district judge for more than three years, presiding over civil disputes, setting bail, authorizing search warrants, conducting preliminary hearings and overseeing trials of summary offenses in areas of the law such as traffic and truancy. He received his law degree from the University of Pittsburgh in 1992, then was a clerk for U.S. District Judge Glenn Mencer before going into private practice, where he concentrated on workplace litigation, including claims of discrimination. Between 1998 and 2007, he was the city of Pittsburgh’s chief labor relations attorney. When he returned to private practice, he became solicitor for the city’s Citizen Police Review Board.
• Mr. Murray, 53, is a specialist in civil litigation, particularly in banking, employment, construction and business law, for the Pittsburgh office of Dinsmore & Shohl, where he is a partner. A graduate of Duquesne Law School and a former clerk for U.S. District Judge Barron McCune, he has been an attorney for 27 years. He also works as an arbitrator and special master for Common Pleas Court. Last year he was voted into the Academy of Trial Lawyers, an honor for litigators in Allegheny County. He has numerous community involvements, including serving on the board of the Fralic Foundation, which supports youth sports activities.
Allegheny County residents deserve the best judges they can get. On Nov. 3, they can’t do any better than electing Jennifer Staley McCrady, Hugh McGough and P.J. Murray.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.