On Wednesday night CNN gave Americans the chance for a second prime-time look at the top Republicans running for president, this time including former Hewlett-Packard CEO Carly Fiorina. The 11 contenders qualified for the main debate based on poll standings, while a lower-performing set of four candidates discussed issues at an earlier event.

Viewers who stuck with the three-hour talk-fest not only became more familiar with the candidates and their positions, but also got to see them snipe at each other. Despite such an investment of time, it’s still hard to sort out the Republican field.

In spite of his limitations, billionaire businessman Donald Trump, one of three political outsiders (along with Ms. Fiorina and retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson), either dominated the debate, as he did the previous event on Aug. 6, or was its focal point.

Among the substantive issues covered were the international deal to curb Iran’s nuclear program, ending funds to Planned Parenthood, legalized same-sex marriage and dealing with Russian leader Vladimir Putin. War surfaced as a topic in several ways, and most of the candidates embraced it as good policy in spite of the costs and alternatives. Discussion of immigration largely focused on the U.S. variety and did not take into account the tragic situation in Europe, where refugees from war-torn Syria and elsewhere are overwhelming the continent’s absorptive capacity.

Advertise with us

The long-running exchange no doubt exceeded many viewers’ attention spans. That’s why some of the candidates should face up to their dim prospects and withdraw from the race so that Republican voters can focus on those with viability. Hearing the present and former governors — Jeb Bush of Florida, Chris Christie of New Jersey, John Kasich of Ohio and Scott Walker of Wisconsin — talk up their state achievements was to be expected, but they would have been more helpful by telling voters what they would do on current, national issues.

The whole exercise of nationally televised debates is valuable in familiarizing Americans with candidates’ platforms and personalities. At the same time, it is early in the game, with the Iowa caucus not until Feb. 1 and the New Hampshire primary Feb. 9.

The public is still waiting for a comparable TV opportunity to size up the Democratic field. Until that debate comes, Americans will have to be content with watching and comparing the Republicans who would be president.

Meet the Editorial Board