When it comes to public records, it sounds like the state Department of Education is just making stuff up.

It’s been a year since Post-Gazette reporters first requested email records of former Acting Secretary Carolyn Dumaresq under the state’s Right-to-Know law. For 12 months, the department has issued various responses, some more implausible than others. The latest revelation is a doozy.

In a letter, the department said Monday that it recently discovered, while responding to a request from the newspaper, a compact disc that it says may possibly contain documents from Ms. Dumaresq, who stepped down in January after 16 months in office. The department said it needs more time because it “attempted to access any information on the disc by consulting the former secretary, along with utilizing available technology at its disposal” yet the “efforts were unsuccessful.”

That sounds an awful lot like the excuse of a teenager trying to keep something away from the prying eyes of Mom and Dad.

Advertise with us

For her part, Ms. Dumaresq said the agency contacted her recently, and she provided her computer password. She said she did not create the disc and that the agency’s technical staff had done so. The department’s explanation just doesn’t make sense. Sadly, that’s not surprising.

Here’s how the department’s failure to have or follow a responsible policy regarding email and other records has played out:

In August 2014, Ms. Dumaresq was asked how it was possible that Ron Tomalis, then Gov. Tom Corbett’s special adviser on higher education, had written only five emails during a year on the job. That suspect detail was the result of the newspaper’s request for his records. Ms. Dumaresq said then that the department’s practice was to purge emails each evening, thus only five.

The newspaper’s legal attempt to see Ms. Dumaresq’s emails — she said 700 of them had been assembled — was backed by the state Office of Open Records but ultimately failed in court. Meanwhile, despite a change in the governor’s office, Pennsylvania’s policy that dates to 1999 still says emails can be discarded and deleted after five days, never to be recovered for public inspection.

That’s ridiculous, and the latest goofy response from the state Education Department is further evidence of it.

Meet the Editorial Board.