Egyptian forces mistakenly killed 12 and wounded 10 members of a tourist party, including Mexicans and Egyptians, in the country’s Western Desert on Sunday. The incident is bound to heighten criticism of Egypt’s military and further hurt tourism.
It is hard to conceive how tourists could be targeted for shelling by army aircraft, given the close attention Egypt’s government has paid to their safety due to tourism’s economic benefits. The convoy of four 4X4 vehicles, organized by an Egyptian hotel, had ventured into the desert. Survivors said that after the air attack, ground forces shot at them.
The Interior Ministry said a combined police and military force mistook the tourists for militants it had been pursuing through the desert.
Last Thursday, the Pentagon announced that the U.S. will be sending more troops to the Sinai Peninsula, which is occupied by Egypt. The United States already has 720 troops based there with the United Nations’ Multinational Force and Observers mission; another 75 are being sent, accompanied by vehicles and weapons.
The problems of the government of President Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi, Egypt’s former field marshal, are threefold. In the Sinai, its forces are threatened by militias loyal to the Islamic State. In Egypt as a whole, the el-Sissi government is challenged by the now underground Muslim Brotherhood, whose leader, Mohamed Morsi, had been overthrown as Egypt’s president in 2013 by the military. Finally, the violence prompted by opposition to the government has caused tourism to dry up, with serious damage to the economy.
The United States is concerned about security in the Sinai because it lies between Egypt and America’s ally Israel. The wisdom of having hundreds of U.S. troops there, however, should be reconsidered as Egypt’s situation deteriorates. The deaths of tourists only highlight the growing danger, and an increase in the U.S. military presence may not make sense.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.