When it comes to euphemisms, it’s hard to beat “restricted housing units.” The term is a dressed-up version of what prison insiders used to call being in “the hole.”
Growing numbers of mental health experts consider it torture. Inmates, often severely mentally ill, assigned to restricted housing are kept in their cells all day except five hours a week for exercise, showering and library visits. Better to call it what it is: solitary confinement.
In a new report, Yale Law School and the Association of State Correctional Administrators have called for eliminating prolonged isolation or, at least, limiting its use to rare cases. Reflecting shifts in attitudes about treatment of inmates, the group laid out the ways in which prolonged isolation affects the mental health of those confined for 23 hours a day in their cells. Going weeks, months, even years without human contact can trigger mental breakdowns and more violence.
Justification for dumping prisoners in the hole range from preventing some from harming others to needing a place to park those awaiting trial. Of the 1.5 million people housed in state prisons, about 66,000 are in some form of restricted housing.
Activists and legal scholars working to end solitary confinement say it may be defensible if used in limited circumstances with clear rules about when a prisoner can be returned to the general prison population. Otherwise, punishment that consists of endless isolation is barbaric.
In Pennsylvania, nearly 2,200 of the 51,000 state inmates were in solitary. This year, that fell to 1,970 in a population of 50,500 prisoners. By mid-2016, due to a legal settlement, the state must stop sending seriously mentally ill inmates to restricted housing. Instead, they may be assigned to “diversionary treatment units” where they can receive treatment and at least 20 hours a week outside their cells.
It’s a step in the right direction, but Pennsylvania — and the nation — must work on getting rid of the hole for good.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.