Humanity’s family album just got a little bit messier. The discovery, announced last Wednesday, of a new species of human relative by a South African research team in a formerly inaccessible cave near Johannesburg has generated headlines around the world.

Two years ago, scientists excavated 1,550 fossil fragments believed to be the remains of at least 15 individuals of a previously unknown species dubbed Homo naledi. Last week, the researchers began publishing the results of their study of the fossils.

The creature, who had long legs, but was less than 5 feet tall, possessed hook-like fingers that probably aided it in tree climbing. It had a relatively large body for a human-like species and walked upright, despite being on the short size compared with Homo sapiens. H. naledi also used tools and had a sense of ritual when it came to disposing of its dead. The fossil fragments were discovered in a cave chamber that had probably been used as an underground graveyard.

The fact that a creature whose brain was the size of an orange engaged in rituals for the dead millions of years ago surprised the scientists who have been studying the fragments. The find is challenging science’s assumptions about human intelligence and brain size.

Advertise with us

Not all scientists have gotten swept up in the hype around H. naledi. University of Pittsburgh anthropologist Jeffrey H. Schwartz is not convinced that the creature should be included in the genus Homo. Mr. Schwartz told the Post-Gazette’s David Templeton that “speculation about burial and rituals is a little bit over the top” because the fragments resemble another primitive hominid genus called Australopithecus.

While it may be premature to enter the findings on H. naledi in Ancestry.com, many scientists believe there’s enough of a resemblance to warrant further investigation. It would be the family thing to do.

Meet the Editorial Board.