Pennsylvania has the nation’s toughest law on recording telephone conversations, requiring consent in advance from all parties on the call. Not so for more modern applications including email, social media, vehicle data recorders and a raft of business uses such as educational software and utility companies.

According to the Privacy Journal, a Rhode Island publisher that has been keeping track of personal information protection for 40 years, Pennsylvania is in the second-lowest quintile among states in providing safeguards for the public.

For example, it lacks rules that prevent employers in 23 other states from demanding workers give the boss their passwords for social media sites they use. Fourteen other states say car manufacturers must tell drivers when vehicle “black boxes” are installed and restrict access to the details they collect. Only six states prohibit anyone, such as an employer, from requiring another person to have an identification device implanted under the skin.

That last example may be further down the road than Pennsylvania needs to go right now, but it is evidence that lawmakers in other parts of the country are looking to the future, rather than playing catch-up with technology that advances quickly every day.

Advertise with us

Some states forbid stores to sell customer data they collect, such as from a supermarket loyalty card; others are attempting to regulate smart TVs and give minors the right to erase any social media they posted as children.

Many security enhancements have been introduced in Harrisburg, but the measures have not made it into law. Recent proposals include making it a crime for a civilian to put a tracking device on another person, limiting the use of drones by government agencies, giving drivers some control over black boxes on their cars and empowering consumers who don’t want utility companies’ so-called smart meters, which some fear give the companies too much information about what happens behind closed doors.

Many advocates for greater protection believe the rules should be set at the federal level. In the absence of a reasonable, national policy, though, the responsibility rests with the states, and Pennsylvania can do a better job of protecting its residents from electronic intrusions.

Meet the Editorial Board.