When it comes to car insurance, customers can be loyal to a fault, paying higher premiums because they neglect to look for better rates, a consumer advocacy group says.

Insurance companies deny punishing drivers for loyalty, but eight states, including Pennsylvania, are suspicious enough to issue stern warnings that the practice is illegal. Consumers, to be safe, had better shop around.

The Consumer Federation of America, based in Washington, D.C., has accused Allstate and other insurers of “price optimization” — setting prices on market factors, rather than a driver’s risk. The consumer group says that nearly 60 percent of consumers pay more than they should for insurance because they fit a profile of customers who never bother to investigate if other companies would offer them better rates. Another consumer advocate, Consumer Reports, has called this the “schmo tax”: a penalty dealt the gullible and loyal.

Another relevant term is price gouging: exploitative pricing based on circumstance, not the cost of a service or good. And here in Pennsylvania, it’s illegal, as Insurance Commissioner Teresa Miller noted in her warning last month to insurers.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Consumer Reports suggests a way around the practice: Drivers should question their rate (especially if it’s gone up), comparison shop on websites like Thezebra.com and think twice before signing up for automatic renewal. In this way, consumers can practice price optimization, too.

Meet the Editorial Board.