Without the promise of sizable subsidies from taxpayers, developers have shown no interest in building a big, full-service hotel near Downtown’s David L. Lawrence Convention Center. It turns out that lack of enthusiasm for a facility of at least 1,000 rooms, the size typically associated with a regional conventional center, extends to the idea of a smaller hotel, too.
After years of failed attempts at luring a big hotel, the Allegheny County-Pittsburgh Sports & Exhibition Authority, which owns and operates the convention center, asked in January for a new round of ideas, either for a full-service hotel with at least 500 rooms or some other use for two parcels of land near the center.
Authority chairman Wayne Fontana, a state senator from Brookline, said the latest submissions include requests for subsidies in the range of $10 million, a big difference from $50 million sought in the past. However, the size of the projects are significantly smaller, too, so what the developers are asking for still may be more than is warranted.
Officials long have argued that the lack of concentrated hotel space is a major reason that Pittsburgh loses out on large conventions. But even officials at VisitPittsburgh, the tourism agency that has led the charge for a big convention center hotel, has adopted a less aggressive position. The group’s CEO and president, Craig Davis, told Post-Gazette reporter Mark Belko that, before moving forward, it wants to analyze the supply and demand for hotel rooms by taking into account the 1,500 rooms now under construction or in the pipeline.
The SEA is doing the same. Mr. Fontana said he thinks an examination of the proposals the SEA received will resume in the fall.
A lot has changed in the hotel market since the convention center opened in 2003. The conclusion very well could be that, despite seeking one for years, the region doesn’t really need a new hotel attached to the center. Officials shouldn’t be afraid to reach that conclusion, especially if the alternative is giving away significant public dollars to make it a reality.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.