To know how much Pittsburgh loves dogs, Michael Vick need only walk a few steps from Heinz Field to see the statue of Rocco, the police dog fatally stabbed by a criminal in January 2014.

This city won’t forget Rocco, nor the crimes that landed Mr. Vick in jail in 2007: financing a dog-fighting ring and violently killing its rejects by drowning, electrocution and strangling. But like it or not, he’s a Steeler now, and Pittsburgh should welcome the quarterback’s talents and accept Mr. Vick’s assertion that he has changed.

Although Mr. Vick served 18 months in jail and completed his probation, many of his critics refuse to put down their stones. For them, prison, ignominy and the interruption of a multimillion-dollar career are not enough; they believe his punishment should include everlasting contempt.

But that’s not how America works. Just about everyone here gets a second chance. Since his release, Mr. Vick has married the mother of his two children, worked with the Humane Society to stop animal cruelty and struggled to recover his past football glory in stints with the Philadelphia Eagles and New York Jets. He even got a dog for his children.

Advertise with us

If Steelers fans should worry about anything, it’s how he will mesh with starting quarterback Ben Roethlisberger and the rest of the team. As recently as last year, Mr. Vick declared, “I’m still a starter. I’m not a backup quarterback.”

He is now, a lingering consequence of horrific conduct nearly a decade ago. But he’s going to get another shot at redemption in Pittsburgh, a once sooty city that knows a thing or two about cleaning up one’s act.

It’s time to put down the stones and let Mr. Vick show who he is now, and — most important for the Steelers — what he can do.

Meet the Editorial Board.

Editor’s note, Aug.27, 12:40 p.m.: The commenting thread on this piece has been closed because it increasingly became dominated by ad hominem attacks, racist comments and offensive remarks, which violate our guide to commenting.