A Texas judge is being lambasted for suggesting that a man marry his girlfriend in order to evade jail — to which Allegheny County can say, been there, done that and it doesn’t work out so great.
In Texas, it was Smith County Judge Randall Rogers who told a 21-year-old man, Josten Bundy, that he could serve 15 days in jail for assault, or marry his 19-year-old girlfriend. Predictably, wedding bells rang, although they were muffled by complaints from the Freedom from Religion Foundation and the bride and groom themselves, who groused at the judge’s insistence that the ceremony take place within 30 days.
But don’t make snarky remarks about Texas, because it happened here, too.
In March, Judge Joseph Williams III heard the case of Quenesia Castaphany, who was charged with reckless endangerment after pouring lighter fluid on her boyfriend and threatening to set him on fire. The judge lectured the couple about their dysfunctional relationship and suggested a lighter sentence might be forthcoming if the pair married. The couple obtained a marriage license that day. (Speed was necessary, because Ms. Castaphany was nine months pregnant with the couple’s fourth child.)
Unfortunately, less than two months later, the newlywed was arrested again, this time for allegedly assaulting her husband and endangering two of their children.
The judges meant well, but to sentence people to marriage is not only fodder for comedians but also judicially sketchy, as coercion is grounds for civil annulment. Much better would be some old-fashioned community service.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.