In 1986, when the Pittsburgh Zoo was accredited by the American Association of Zoological Parks and Aquariums, officials said it was a “real feather in the cap” of the zoo.

“Every zoo that is any zoo at all belongs to this organization,” said Charles Wikenhauser, the zoo’s director at the time.

Mr. Wikenhauser is gone, and 29 years later, so is the Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium’s much-lauded accreditation. The zoo announced Monday that it has ended its relationship with the group because of its new, stricter requirements over elephant keeping. It’s difficult to see how this is a good thing for Pittsburgh or its elephants.

The accrediting group, now called the Association of Zoos & Aquariums, issued a testy statement, saying the zoo “decided their status quo was preferable to complying with the AZA’s more rigorous occupational safety standards related to caring for elephants.” Barbara Baker, CEO of the Pittsburgh Zoo, was equally terse, citing a “philosophical difference of opinion.”

Advertise with us

At issue are the AZA’s new rules that require accredited zoos to drastically limit direct human contact with elephants and keep them behind secure barriers. Advocates say this assures that elephants are never chained or prodded with bull hooks, and that it keeps humans safe.

Ms. Baker declined to speak about why the zoo chose not to comply. Presumably, converting from “free contact” to “protected contact” would be expensive and also would end the zoo’s practice of using Australian cattle dogs to keep distance between elephants and their handlers.

Whatever the value of that program (and we applauded it back in February), it’s not as important as the AZA’s accreditation. Fewer than 10 percent of 2,800 animal exhibits in the United States meet the group’s rigorous standards, and its members include highly regarded zoos in San Diego, Denver and Memphis, plus the National Zoo in Washington, D.C., and the Central Park Zoo in New York — in short, almost every zoo that is any zoo — except Pittsburgh’s. Moreover, the loss of accreditation could prevent the zoo from exchanging animals with AZA zoos and jeopardize its breeding program.

The zoo’s leaders, including its board of directors, have created a wonderful zoo. But they failed Pittsburgh by settling for accreditation by a lesser group whose members include Animal World & Snake Farm Zoo in Texas and Oswald’s Bear Ranch in Michigan. They should work out their differences with the AZA and seek its approval again.

Meet the Editorial Board.