For a bank customer making a deposit, the best protection against error is checking your math and making sure the total on the bank receipt matches the amount on your deposit slip. Then look for the figure later in your monthly statement.

Simple, right?

Except few customers apparently do that. Citizens Bank, which does business in 12 states, wasn’t doing it either.

But that didn’t stop the second-largest retail bank in the Pittsburgh region from pocketing the extra money that many customers mistakenly gave it between 2008 and nearly all of 2013.

Advertise with us

Fortunately, the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which shields the public from abusive financial practices, worked with other regulators to investigate after hearing from a whistleblower. Last week the federal agencies said Citizens Bank will be required to pay refunds of $11 million to individuals and $3 million to businesses, plus $20.5 million in civil penalties.

The unprecedented punishment against a major bank for deposit-related activity comes because Citizens chose to ignore the discrepancies between deposit slips and the actual money it received. Richard Cordray, the consumer bureau’s director, said Citizens “harmed many consumers by pocketing the difference.”

The discrepancies ignored by the bank on at least 475,000 accounts were $50 or less and were due to either customer math error or bank scanners that did not record the correct amount on checks and deposit slips. The customers who mistakenly were over-credited by the bank will get to keep the extra cash.

The Post-Gazette’s Patricia Sabatini reported that besides paying the fines and refunds, Citizens Bank must change how it collects and records deposits.

To Citizens Bank this is a costly lesson, both financially and in the all-important category of trust. It should put all other banks on notice. Consumers can learn something from this, too: In an era when many people have cell phones and many cell phones have calculators, there’s just no excuse not to do the math.

Meet the Editorial Board.