Inflammatory statements by a Planned Parenthood executive during a meeting that was surreptitiously filmed and released this week have reignited the public debate over abortion.

A congressional hearing may well be the best way to clear the air regarding the organization’s policies; the insensitive remarks of Deborah Nucatola, Planned Parenthood’s senior director of medical services, are another matter.

Although a transcript of the video seems to rebut the claim by anti-abortion groups that Planned Parenthood is selling fetus parts, the images of an executive casually discussing how abortions must be performed to preserve organs is disturbing. The organization did not help itself with an initial response that was starched and insufficient.

Dr. Nucatola thought she was meeting buyers from the Fetal Tissue Procurement Co. to discuss how Planned Parenthood could supply aborted fetal tissue for research. Instead, her lunch was with two actors working for a California group called the Center for Medical Progress.

Advertise with us

In the video, Dr. Nucatola explains that tissue can be preserved only when specific procedures are followed, and her gruesome descriptions are all the more disturbing because they come between sips of wine and bites of salad.

When asked about prices, Dr. Nucatola said $30 to $100 “per specimen,” prompting abortion foes to accuse Planned Parenthood of selling fetal parts, which is illegal. The 60-page transcript, however, suggests the charges were for shipping, and Dr. Nucatola said donating fetal remains for research is a public service.

“Everybody just sees this as a way to add another layer of good on top of what they are doing. They already feel that what they are doing is good,” she said. Naturally, that is a matter of opinion that fuels the nation’s ongoing discord over abortion.

Abortion is legal, as is the donation of fetal tissue for research. It’s important that the public know for certain that Planned Parenthood’s actions are too. If a House Judiciary Committee investigation can clear up any questions, it will be worthwhile.

Meanwhile, the organization’s executives need to be more careful in their language.

Meet the Editorial Board.