Like paid vacation or all-you-can-drink coffee, paid sick leave is a generous benefit offered by many employers. But neither the state of Pennsylvania nor the federal government demands that companies pay employees for not working. Neither should the city of Pittsburgh.

Even the enthusiasm of city Councilman Corey O’Connor can’t make this a good idea: to punish Pittsburgh businesses that don’t offer paid sick leave that employees can use for themselves or family members. Mr. O’Connor’s proposal tells business owners exactly how much sick time they must extend: one hour for every 30 hours worked — up to 72 hours for employers with 15 or more workers, up to 40 hours for businesses with fewer than 15 workers. Businesses that don’t comply would be fined $100 for each violation, adding sick-leave enforcement to Grant Street’s to-do list, already groaning.

Proponents of paid sick leave, President Barack Obama among them, argue that workers shouldn’t have to decide between going to work sick and paying their bills. But this argument ignores the fact that businesses, too, have bills, and there’s no such thing as free sick leave.

In fact, companies that offer it often pay twice — the wages of the person taking time off and the wages of the person who performs the job while another is off. That’s a hit that some businesses can’t afford, especially on top of increasing pressure to hike wages. Eleven states have passed bills forbidding municipalities from mandating paid sick leave; a similar one is pending in Harrisburg.

Advertise with us

Paid sick leave is a perk, not a right. That doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be offered to workers, but companies that can’t afford it shouldn’t be punished. The decision should be made by employers, not by the city.

Meet the Editorial Board.