One of the U.S. Supreme Court’s end-of-term decisions that didn’t get front-page play was its defense of a key principle of federal law that has protected millions of Americans from housing discrimination.

The ruling has implications not just for landlords and mortgage lenders — the traditional defendants in fair housing cases — but also for state and local housing policy.

The decision breaks from the precedent set in a 1977 case, in which the high court held that plaintiffs in housing discrimination cases had to prove discriminatory intent. The current case involves a Texas government agency that was accused of violating the federal Fair Housing Act in the way it issued federal tax credits for low-income housing in Dallas. The state had disproportionately located low-income housing in majority-black neighborhoods, which reinforced patterns of residential segregation, a local nonprofit group alleged.

The Supreme Court ruled that the Texas policy’s “disparate impact” on African-American communities was enough to prove that discrimination had occurred, regardless of intent. The disparate-impact standard already had been applied in this manner for decades and had been upheld by most federal courts. But some institutions, especially banks that profit from discriminatory lending practices, have tried to dismantle it.

Advertise with us

Opponents of the standard argue that it would prevent housing agencies from pursuing good policies that could result in a disparate impact. A developer might, for example, choose to locate low-income housing near public transit and inadvertently build in mostly minority neighborhoods. But the court said defendants still have the opportunity to show that their policies are justified even if they result in a disparate impact.

The court’s decision is supported by decades of fair-housing litigation that has relied on the disparate-impact standard to ensure all Americans have equal access to decent housing and economic opportunity. The justices properly remind us that even today, public policy, not just private action, can be a source of segregation. It should motivate communities across America to do better.

Meet the Editorial Board