In 1812, the governor of Massachusetts persuaded the legislature to redraw the lines of a congressional district in a way that would benefit his political party. The governor was Elbridge Gerry, and the shape of the new district resembled a salamander, prompting a newspaper to dub the process “gerrymandering.”
The name stuck, as did the practice, unfortunately. Though widely decried, it continued for the next two centuries, with legislators insisting that the Constitution gave them the right to draw legislative lines. Recently, the U.S. Supreme Court disagreed, ruling that states can appoint independent panels to design congressional districts. Seven states have done so, and Pennsylvania should swiftly move to join them.
Federal law mandates that legislative districts be tweaked every 10 years to reflect new census data. Legislators, however, often seize that opportunity to craft nonsensical boundaries that protect incumbents and improve the election prospects of the party in control. It is a practice for which Americans increasingly have no tolerance. Last week, the Florida Supreme Court rejected a gerrymandered plan that favored Republicans.
The case the U.S. Supreme Court decided stemmed from an independent commission that reform-minded Arizona created in 2000. Two years later, the state’s Legislature sued, saying the redistricting was unconstitutional. But in a 5-4 ruling, the justices reminded legislators that “all political power flows from the people.”
Here in Pennsylvania, the congressional reapportionment commission comprises four legislators — two senators and two House members, two Democrats and two Republicans — and together the four select a chairman. That should ensure fairness, but it often has not: In 2012, RealClearPolitics dubbed the commonwealth’s creation of 12 heavily Republican districts the “Gerrymander of the Decade.” Let’s not win that title again.
State Rep. Ted Harhai, D-Monessen, has introduced a bill that would create a citizens commission to handle redistricting and ensure that the districts do not unnecessarily divide municipalities. With the Supreme Court saying this is legal, it’s time to act and call gerrymandering what it is: a practice that should have been discarded in the 19th century.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.