If only Hillary Clinton had been a Pennsylvania state employee. Then, according to the Commonwealth Court, she could have zapped her emails into oblivion with impunity.

That was the decision of three Commonwealth Court judges who ruled last week on the Post-Gazette’s challenge of a confounding practice: State employees routinely deleting emails that are a record of how Pennsylvania is governed. With email the primary form of written communication in the digital age, the preservation of these records is essential. The newspaper will appeal to the state Supreme Court.

The Post-Gazette believes the email of Pennsylvania government workers — who generate 5 million such missives a week — should be preserved for at least two years on a central server. Currently, public employees can delete them at will, and they are permanently erased five days after deletion.

This enables both elected officials and lifelong employees to purge emails they deem non-essential, erasing records whose value may not be apparent until months or years later. It also gives them cover for deleting important emails that could be damaging under public scrutiny. Ms. Clinton, the Democratic presidential candidate, has been widely criticized for selective retention of her correspondence when she was secretary of state.

Advertise with us

In Pennsylvania, the issue came to light when the Post-Gazette sought access to emails former Education Secretary Ron Tomalis wrote and received during the administration of former Gov. Tom Corbett. The newspaper was given only five and told Mr. Tomalis likely had deleted the other correspondence.

Joined by other Pennsylvania newspapers, the Post-Gazette sued the state, asserting that the destruction of such records violates the spirit of Pennsylvania’s Right to Know law. In dismissing the challenge, the Commonwealth Court noted that the law does not prohibit the destruction of records or specify an amount of time they should be saved. It simply says the public has the right to inspect records that still exist.

That doesn’t make sense. Allowing employees to choose what emails should be available for later review is like letting the fox count the chickens each morning. All email correspondence of government officials and employees should be saved, at minimum, for two years.

Meet the Editorial Board.