The best American companies operate under principles of openness and transparency. But Mylan, the Cecil-based generic drugs giant, left its shareholders in the dark by not disclosing the details of a major 2012 land deal.
The transaction, which was used to build the corporation’s new headquarters, involved its lead independent director, Rodney L. Piatt. A real estate developer, Mr. Piatt was the part-owner of a company that sold a 7-acre tract in Washington County’s Southpointe development for $1 to a firm partly owned by a business partner. The firm immediately sold the land for $2.9 million to Mylan, which unveiled plans the next day to construct its headquarters there.
The Wall Street Journal reported the details of the purchases on Tuesday. Additional articles this week by the Post-Gazette aired the concerns of securities lawyers over certain transactions that are not disclosed to shareholders. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission requires corporations to report the specifics of certain kinds of transactions that involve people with close ties to the firm.
Mr. Piatt has been a director at Mylan since 2004 and is chairman of its compensation committee, which sets the pay for top Mylan executives.
Through its spokespeople, Mylan said the company has met its disclosure requirements on related-party transactions and that Mr. Piatt was not a party to either transaction. Others were critical of Mylan, however.
Irwin Kishner, a securities lawyer, told the Post-Gazette’s Len Boselovic that some related-party deals can be good for shareholders, but they should still be scrutinized. “To me, this one is obvious,” he said. “How can you possibly think that this was not a disclosable transaction?”
Charles Elson, who runs the University of Delaware’s Center for Corporate Governance, said, “An independent director should not be involved in related-party transactions. It compromises their independence.”
And that’s why openness is so important, regardless of whether Mylan was required to disclose this transaction: The integrity of an independent director, whose obligation is to protect shareholder interests, must not be compromised even by appearances.
Mylan’s shareholders should demand an explanation for why they were not told about this land deal three years ago. Given their investments in the company, they are owed that much, and Mylan’s leaders should be eager to earn and keep their trust.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.