“How not to run a school system.” That could have been the title page of a state audit completed on the Baldwin-Whitehall School District.

The 27-page report that state Auditor General Eugene A. DePasquale released last week describes a dysfunctional bureaucracy that didn’t carefully handle taxpayers’ money. The audit said the school board “frequently exercised poor governance,” didn’t keep track of credit/​debit cards, improperly hired a former board member for an administrative job and couldn’t adequately document some student records — an error that could cost it $343,061 if the state tries to recoup.

To make matters worse, the audit was a bit of a rerun. In 2009, the state had recommended ways the district could keep better track of its money after auditors determined that $298,556 was missing. (An employee whom police described as “a person of interest” subsequently was found dead of a suspected suicide.) Despite that error, Baldwin-Whitehall didn’t make the changes until recently, affecting its activity, athletic and cafeteria funds, payroll and more.

The audit singled out its 2013 decision to hire former board member Martin Schmotzer for $120,000 a year right after he resigned his elected position, saying it violated the Public School Code and sidestepped rules that require advertising such a hire. Another sign of disarray at the top is the revolving door of administrators — two superintendents, four business managers and seven treasurers in the past seven years.

Advertise with us

The district responded that it is addressing many of the concerns. It says it is developing a uniform set of procedures for its business operation and has stopped using the debit/​credit cards, which had credit limits of $10,000 to $500,000. But talk is cheap; in 2009, the then-superintendent also said improvements would be made.

Fortunately, residents are paying attention. They forced Mr. Schmotzer’s resignation two years ago, and they’re going to have to keep close tabs on the elected board and appointed staff members. Promises are cheap, and failing to fulfill them can be costly.

Meet the Editorial Board