The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling Thursday upholding federal tax subsidies under the Affordable Care Act means that millions of middle-class and poor Americans — including 400,000 in Pennsylvania — will remain able to buy the health insurance they need. That is a crucial, even life-saving, outcome.
More broadly, the 6-3 decision helps ensure that the health-care reform law, President Barack Obama’s chief legislative accomplishment, will endure after he leaves office in 2017. Despite the strenuous, if futile, efforts by his Republican antagonists in Congress to kill it, Obamacare will remain part of the nation’s critical safety net. That’s as it should be, because the law is working.
The court’s opinion in King v. Burwell arose from a legal challenge by Obamacare foes to an Internal Revenue Service interpretation of the health care law. At issue was a provision of the law that creates online marketplaces where consumers can buy private, individual health insurance. Although 16 states have set up their own insurance exchanges, the rest — including Pennsylvania — rely on an exchange run by the federal government, healthcare.gov.
Roughly 85 percent of Americans who buy health insurance from exchanges have incomes low enough to qualify for government tax credits that help them afford the coverage. Those subsidies average $272 a month. Across the nation, more than 6 million Americans use the tax credits. Eight out of 10 Pennsylvanians get assistance and pay an average of $129 a month for coverage.
The IRS said the subsidies are available on both state and federal exchanges. The plaintiffs, in a cramped reading of the Affordable Care Act, argued that the subsidies did not apply to the federal exchange because the law refers to “an exchange established by the state.”
But Chief Justice John Roberts Jr., writing for the majority, properly observed: “Congress passed the Affordable Care Act to improve health insurance markets, not to destroy them ... [We] must interpret the act in a way that is consistent with the former, and avoids the latter.”
The court victory does not mean that the Affordable Care Act needs no further work. Many of the private insurers on the state and federal exchanges are preparing to raise premiums this fall, in some cases by as much as 65 percent. And despite the solid gains the law has achieved, up to 35 million Americans remain uninsured.
But the ruling will allow the insurance exchanges to continue to develop and to serve more consumers. It will enable the rate of uninsured Americans — now approaching the lowest point in history — to decline further.
Meanwhile, even the most fervent, die-hard opponents of Obamacare need to admit defeat. Congress has wasted its tax-funded time on more than 50 occasions voting to repeal or undermine the Affordable Care Act. It’s over.
After the court ruling, Mr. Obama correctly asserted that “health care is not a privilege for a few, but a right for all.” If lawmakers of either party have ways to strengthen the law, let’s see them.
But fighting, and losing, the last war isn’t going to lower the cost of health care, broaden access to it or improve its quality. That’s where the national debate needs to move now.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.