“Where do our rights come from?” That’s a philosophical question, but if meant literally, it has a simple answer: Runnymede, England. That’s where 800 years ago on June 15, King John signed Magna Carta, a document out of which has grown many of the world’s present freedoms.
In its specifics, Magna Carta dealt with some matters that appear to bear little relevance to natural rights, the rights that people supposedly have under natural law. The landmark document pronounced on inheritances for widows, the release of hostages, the proper use of forests. And it reflected the thinking of the age, with clauses that forbade women to testify in court and nullified certain debts owed to Jews.
But Magna Carta also contained the seeds of democracy. It limited the king’s ability to tax nobles without their approval, to convict them without due process and to seize public lands for his own use. King John and his descendants could not rule without the consent of the governed, meaning monarchs, too, would bow to legal principles and institutions.
Magna Carta’s protections applied mostly to noblemen, and it guaranteed rights on the basis of mutual obligations between them and the crown. After John’s failed wars, fights with the pope and demands for new revenue, the lords had merely wanted to check his power. But in the centuries that followed, thinkers such as John Locke and Thomas Jefferson would re-conceive rights as the entitlement of all, regardless of circumstance. And in linking political and economic freedom, presidents such as Franklin Roosevelt would expand upon one of the document’s central insights.
Natural rights theory has its discontents, even within the liberal tradition; utilitarian philosopher Jeremy Bentham called the idea “nonsense upon stilts.” Nonetheless, it has persisted and become part of the social fabric, leading to ferocious debates about what government can and cannot do. Even in this modern age, free people must recognize that it all began with Magna Carta.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.