The Plum school board is angry about the intense scrutiny it’s been getting from the news media lately. Really? That’s the takeaway from allegations that two teachers were having sex with students and a third is accused of trying to intimidate an accuser?

Trying to kill the messenger is not going to change the fact that the allegations are damning and that, so far, the district’s various and lame responses to questions about the incidents are appallingly lacking.

Plum administrators and school board members need to readjust their thinking in a big way.

Joseph Tommarello, who resigned as a board member because of the district’s response to the scandal, said he alerted the district back in 2012 of suspicions that high school English teacher Joseph Ruggieri was having sex with a student. The district has said it investigated the claim in 2011, before Mr. Tommarello’s assertion, and found it to be baseless. He said he made a second allegation in 2014, which the district denies.

Advertise with us

While the district says the 2011 inquiry was conducted by an on-site Plum police officer, Plum Chief Jeffrey Armstong said his office has no record of such a thing and the officer’s attorney says his client is being made a scapegoat.

Nonetheless, the district has dug in its heels, claiming the rightness of how it dealt with the allegation. At this point, it’s pretty obvious that the district should be re-examining how it handles a serious matter such as this.

On Wednesday, board President Sal Colella read a statement in which he said the district’s lips are sealed because of an ongoing investigation by the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office that is now before a grand jury. The truth is, even if board members are called to testify before that panel, they would not be bound by any confidentiality requirement. The constraints on talking about grand jury investigations apply to the investigators, not to potential or actual witnesses.

Whether Plum officials want to admit it or not, there is a crisis enveloping them, and the public deserves far more answers than they’ve provided so far.

Meet the Editorial Board