Anthony Elonis of Northampton County doesn’t sound like a guy you’d want to spend a lot of time with. After his wife left him, he posted violent comments about her on Facebook (“I’m not going to rest until your body is a mess, soaked in blood and dying ...”). The Pennsylvania man expanded his rhetorical targets to include former co-workers, local police, an FBI agent and a kindergarten class.
He was convicted of violating a federal law that prohibits communication of threats to harm others and served nearly four years in prison before he was released in 2014. Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned that conviction, saying prosecutors should have had to meet a tougher standard than simply showing that a “reasonable person” would have interpreted his vile posts as credible, direct threats.
The decision would have been more helpful if the high court had not replaced one vague legal standard with a new one. Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the majority, ruled that Mr. Elonis’ intent and state of mind when he wrote the posts were the key issues, not what a reasonable person would infer.
Yet the ruling did not require prosecutors to show that a defendant intended to pose a threat as a prerequisite to criminal punishment; Justice Roberts said it would be sufficient to prove that he or she had “knowledge” that the words would be considered threatening.
Mr. Elonis had argued that his posts were merely “therapeutic,” that he was assuming the “persona” of a rapper and that he did not intend his threatening language to be taken seriously.
The Internet, sadly, has become a repository of hateful, abusive, even violent speech. Terrorist groups use social media to recruit followers, often with the language of violence.
Seeking to punish such speech with criminal prosecution needs to surmount a high bar. But the freedom to engage in violent speech cannot be absolute, for targets of such speech also have rights. The Supreme Court’s ruling does too little to draw appropriate lines to show when speech becomes a crime.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.