Aside from a bruising court battle with Highmark, add to UPMC’s woes rule-breaking in its medical division. On Monday, the United Network for Organ Sharing, the nonprofit group in charge of transplants, put the hospital system on probation for bumping its own patients to the front of the line for lungs.

When a lung becomes available, it’s supposed to be assigned to someone based on that individual’s rank on a waiting list. Sometimes the potential recipient — already too weak to undergo surgery — passes on the transplant. In that case, health care providers must make the lung available to the waiting list, so that it can be given to the next person in line.

UPMC deviated from that norm, and instead transplanted lungs into “backup patients” it selected internally. It pleads ignorance for the rules breach, says it had approval from the organ procurement organizations to have a backup recipient ready and claims it now complies with all regulations. Under the terms of its probation, it promises to implement safeguards against such mistakes in the future.

But Western Pennsylvania’s largest hospital network should have known better, and it’s not the first time it has gotten into trouble. In 2011, UPMC unwittingly allowed the transplant of a hepatitis-infected kidney, a slip-up that earned it a previous term of probation from UNOS.

Advertise with us

Usually recovered from cadavers, lungs for transplant are limited in supply. According to Johns Hopkins Hospital, patients can spend up to three years on the waiting list depending on their medical profile. In the end stages of respiratory disease, most transplant candidates have little time left, and for some, help arrives too late.

The order in which patients receive lungs can be a matter of life and death. UPMC must respect protocol and ensure these decisions are made in a fair and transparent manner.

Meet the Editorial Board.