Replacement this week of some provisions of the post-9/11 USA Patriot Act by the new USA Freedom Act will limit government surveillance of bulk data on Americans’ phone communications.
The hokey names for both laws belie their sweeping and, many would say, intrusive impact. The new statute was passed Tuesday on a 67-32 vote in the Senate and quickly signed by President Barack Obama. Its predecessor, much of which will continue in its original form, was enacted in the panicked weeks after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.
Under the reform, the National Security Agency will no longer collect bulk communications made by millions of Americans. The phone companies will hold the metadata — the time a phone call was made, how long it lasted and to whom it was made. The metadata does not have the content of the call. U.S. security agencies will have to request information on individuals and obtain a court order before getting access to the data from the companies.
Americans may hold conflicting views on NSA whistleblower Edward J. Snowden, who is still in exile in Russia, and Sen. Rand Paul, who launched a filibuster against the effort by his fellow Kentucky Republican, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, to extend the Patriot Act. But it was Mr. Snowden’s action that revealed the excessive NSA surveillance and Mr. Paul’s goal-line stand on the Senate floor that reined it in.
The process that led to the new rules, which will last through 2019, did not reflect well on Congress. It was a House of Representatives version of the bill that finally passed, but not until the Senate, under ineffective leadership by Mr. McConnell, revealed sharp divisions in its Republican majority and differences with Republicans leading the House.
The final product, however — new rules for government scrutiny of Americans’ communications data — is an improvement over the law passed in haste after 9/11.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.