Like students who take their courses on a pass/​fail basis because they don’t want to risk getting less than an A, Allegheny County restaurant owners lobbied long and hard against an A-B-C grade health inspection system.

They won on Tuesday, when county council bowed to their fear-mongering and delivered a stunning 12-1 defeat of the plan, which had the backing of county Executive Rich Fitzgerald and his health director, Karen Hacker.

The grading proposal has been under consideration and revision for years, and it received its biggest advance in September, when the county Board of Health voted 6-1 to send it to council for approval. The relentless campaign by opponents won the day, based on the restaurateurs’ assertions — exaggerated — that insignificant violations could earn them less than an A rating, which in turn could drive them out of business.

Mr. Fitzgerald, who is accustomed to seeing his proposals sail through council, where his fellow Democrats hold a 10-5 majority, said he thought the plan was doomed by a lack of publicly stated support for it. If a referendum were held, he said, he thought the measure would pass, but residents didn’t lobby council members for it.

Advertise with us

“We just never got a lot of emails or calls and neither did council,” he said, contrasting that to adamant public demands for a countywide ban on smoking in restaurants, a measure that passed in 2006 only to be overturned in court and subsequently replaced by statewide smoking restrictions two years later. This time, council members heard only from the spirited opponents.

Council’s vote will have no effect on the process that county health inspectors use to assess restaurant compliance with food-handling standards. It just means diners won’t get the kind of clear indication of how well establishments did on inspections, something people have come to expect in other locations, including restaurant titan New York City. A study of that city’s grading program found that, after implementation, sanitary conditions improved.

It only makes sense. Students who fear a lower grade but don’t have the option of taking a class pass/​fail just might work harder to do better. Allegheny County diners deserve that same level of care from the restaurants they patronize. Too bad council didn’t demand it of them.

Meet the Editorial Board