Most of the noise in this year’s election campaign for controller is coming from the Allegheny County race, but there’s another controller’s office on the ballot, this one in the city of Pittsburgh.
Michael Lamb, 52, of Mount Washington, is completing his second four-year term and would like another. Natalia Rudiak, 35, of Carrick, who has represented South Hills neighborhoods in District 4 on city council for six years, would like to replace him. Their campaigns are quiet compared to the county race — incumbent Chelsa Wagner faces former Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty — but there are similarities.
In the city race, as in the county, the current officeholder is being challenged by someone favored by the chief elected officer — Executive Rich Fitzgerald on the county side and Mayor Bill Peduto in the city. In both instances, having that support from the higher-up is more negative than positive.
Why? Because the controller is the fiscal watchdog, the second-highest elected official and the one charged with making sure the governmental departments operate efficiently and spend taxpayer money wisely. The very nature of the position gives the political outsider an advantage over the insider.
That’s not the only reason Mr. Lamb deserves the Democratic Party’s nomination in the primary, a near mandate for a third term since no Republican is on the ballot to challenge next month’s winner.
Mr. Lamb had been the county’s prothonotary before he and others successfully advocated for a change in the structure of county government that included elimination of that row office and a handful of others. In the last two years, he has completed 13 fiscal audits of various city department accounts and 11 more detailed performance audits that examined various departments and authorities, all available on his website. As required by ordinance, his office produces an annual Comprehensive Annual Financial Report each May and Mr. Lamb also has produced the more accessible, summary version, the Popular Annual Financial Report, since 2009.
Much of the criticism lobbed by Ms. Rudiak seems to be off target, particularly regarding the city’s failure to implement a new payroll system and past corruption in the police bureau.
The payroll module was part of a 2011 joint city-county agreement for a comprehensive financial management system. Mr. Peduto stopped the project when he took office and learned costs had mushroomed from $264,000 to more than $1.2 million, based on change orders requested by the firm doing the work and approved by the city’s former in-house project manager. If Mr. Lamb is culpable, the responsibility would have to be shared by the previous mayoral administration and city council, which failed to provide adequate oversight.
Ms. Rudiak’s suggestion that police corruption, which resulted in the former police chief being sentenced to prison, was able to fester because Mr. Lamb was not properly auditing the books is flat-out absurd.
Both candidates are city natives, well educated and dedicated to Pittsburgh’s future. Ms. Rudiak has been a productive, forward-looking member of council, but her campaign website reads more like an audition for mayor than a manual on how to be controller.
Michael Lamb would be the better watchdog and he has earned the Post-Gazette endorsement.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.