Everybody hates to pay for parking. Is there a driver out there who hasn’t circled a block in search of a free place before surrendering to the inevitable, available pay lot or a space with a meter? It’s obvious why free spaces at many of the Port Authority’s park-n-ride lots throughout Allegheny County are an attractive option for commuters.
They may be a luxury the transit agency no longer can afford.
Port Authority Chairman Robert Hurley brought up the topic as members considered a proposal to buy a lot on McKnight Road in McCandless, one that has 250 spaces but that could be expanded to 400. The authority has negotiated a $1.6 million price for the 4.25 acres, which naturally raised the question of operating and maintenance costs going forward. There also are questions of whether the cost of installing pay stations would be higher than the revenue they’d collect and whether the additional sum — county Executive Rich Fitzgerald said it might be as low as $1 a day — would be the tipping point that dissuades motorists from using public transit.
The authority needs to conduct a comprehensive analysis to find the answers, which probably will differ among the 49 lots in operation. The Port Authority already knows that its garage at South Hills Village sits half-empty on most weekdays even though the price charged is $2, while a privately owned lot near the Memorial Hill Station on its light-rail transit line fills to capacity despite a $4 fee.
When it comes to parking, supply and demand is a model that works, which explains why parking Downtown and in Oakland costs more than in some other neighborhood business districts. Setting the right price, if any, will be key.
If the Port Authority charges for parking at lots that are free now — in effect a fare increase — it had better be sure that the bus and light-rail service there is ready to meet the demand. Imagine how upset commuters will be if, after they’ve paid to park, a bus or train arrives late or is so crowded that they can’t get on.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.