If the proposal Republican Sen. Pat Toomey introduced last week sounds familiar, that’s because it’s the same one he pitched last year.

The legislation, co-sponsored by Democratic Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia, aims to keep sexual predators away from school children by stepping up background checks and prohibiting schools from hiring anyone convicted of violent or sexual crimes. It also forbids school districts from recommending suspected abusers for positions in other states.

“I can’t believe this is even controversial,” said Mr. Toomey, still incredulous that last year’s measure never made it out of committee, although the House approved its version unanimously. His frustration is warranted, as is the bipartisan plan, which codifies common-sense practices that should have been law years ago.

Senators who stonewalled the 2014 bill said Congress shouldn’t act as a school board and states already have their own rules about background checks. That’s precisely the problem. States vary wildly in what checks they require, and they don’t always communicate with each other. Pennsylvania does it right, requiring three checks (Department of Human Services, state police and FBI) every 36 months, for both regular and contract employees. But 12 states don’t require background checks on contract employees at all.

Advertise with us

Mr. Toomey, the father of three, notes that while most teachers and other school employees are honorable, the abuse of children in school settings is “not an isolated event.” In 2014, 459 school workers were arrested in the United States for sexual misconduct, 26 of them in Pennsylvania.

The new measures might not have prevented all those abuses, but they might have saved Jeremy Bell. He was the 12-year-old West Virginia boy who was raped and killed in 1997 by his principal, a former Pennsylvania teacher who had been suspected of abusing boys in Delaware County, but was still able to get a job one state away.

Motivated by that tragedy and the potential for others, Mr. Toomey vows to keep pushing, saying, “We’re going to vote on this, one way or the other.” Now attached to a controversial sex-trafficking bill, it may fail again, but Mr. Toomey is right to keep trying.

Meet the Editorial Board