Trust. It’s what clients, large and small, seek to have in the professionals who handle their hard-earned money. Yet BNY Mellon failed the test of trust in a costly way.

Last week, the financial institution, part of which had a storied past in Pittsburgh and which now is based in New York, agreed to pay $714 million to settle federal and state charges that it defrauded clients by adding hidden spreads to foreign currency trades performed on the customers’ behalf.

According to a joint release from government prosecutors, BNY Mellon “obtained the best FX rates for itself, gave its customers the worst or close to the worst rates and kept the difference for itself.”

Preet Bharara, U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, said the trust and custody giant and its executives were “motivated by outsized profits and bonuses” to deceive pension funds and other institutional clients in a scheme that lasted 10 years.

Advertise with us

The official price of BNY Mellon’s fraud will be $335 million split by the United States and New York state, another $335 million to address class action lawsuits filed by customers, $30 million to the Securities and Exchange Commission and $14 million to the Labor Department. The settlement also mandates the firing of key executives.

The greater price that will be paid is the loss of trust in BNY Mellon, which is sure to follow. Financial pros can buy attention for their services, but they can’t buy the faith and confidence of customers. That, for those driven by the big bonus, has to be earned.

Meet the Editorial Board