Why should Pennsylvanians care how the U.S. Supreme Court decides a case challenging the authority of Arizona’s independent election reapportioning commission? Because the outcome could kill any hope that Pennsylvania or 49 other states will eliminate political gerrymandering from the process of setting up congressional districts.

On Monday, the court heard arguments on Arizona State Legislature v. Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission. The case is the result of a challenge to a 2000 referendum in which Arizona voters created a commission to draw congressional districts instead of having the legislature do it. California is the only other state where such a commission was created by referendum, but 15 other states have nonpartisan or bipartisan commissions to draw the lines, and similar efforts are being considered in a dozen states.

Recent Pennsylvania elections show why an impartial redistricting system — one not touched by the hands of politicians — is necessary.

In 2012, President Barack Obama won 53 percent of the ballots cast in Pennsylvania, illustrating a near even split between voters who chose a Democrat and those who chose a Republican. Nonetheless, Republicans won 13 of 18 congressional seats. How could that happen? The state Legislature, at the time under the control of Republicans, drew congressional districts that could easily be won by members of that party.

Advertise with us

The prospects for mischief are present regardless of which party is in control when districts are revised every 10 years. Too many districts are drawn with preordained outcomes, with lopsided registration numbers favoring one party. This all but eliminates tight contests and real choices for voters.

If the court agrees with the Arizona legislature, which argues that only it has authority to set district borders, it could also be the kiss of death for ballot initiatives.

The Supreme Court has a chance to make sure voters have a real say in electing Congress, or it can give the green light to future voter manipulation through gerrymandering.

Meet the Editorial Board