Judges in most criminal trials have flexibility in sentencing, and usually that’s a good thing. But in the case of Gisele Paris, the Spring Hill woman who was found guilty of taking and later euthanizing a neighbor’s Siberian husky, Judge Anthony M. Mariani gave the offender light punishment.
Don’t take our word for it, just listen to Judge Mariani.
Ms. Paris, 58, was found guilty in December of theft, receiving stolen property and cruelty to animals. At Friday’s sentencing hearing in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, the judge severely admonished her, saying “the essence of the case was more about cruelty than theft” and that she “showed no remorse” and posed a danger to the community “because she believes she can do whatever she wants.”
The judge continued to fume: “I don’t see anything to indicate that you understand the wrongfulness of your conduct.”
For all the outrage Judge Mariani professed at Ms. Paris’s wicked action in ordering the death of Thor, he failed to sentence her to meaningful punishment.
Although the maximum penalty for her crimes was 10 years in prison, judicial sentencing guidelines which take into consideration the offender’s prior criminal record (Ms. Paris had none) can reduce the length of a sentence. Even so, the punishment rendered by the judge — three to six months in jail, two years’ probation and a $1,000 fine — hardly matched the cruelty that was committed, particularly to Thor’s true owner, Mark Boehler, who has Stage 3 esophageal cancer.
It is one thing for a judge to go on in court about the dreadful deeds committed by a defendant, in this case a heinous act in which an animal and a man were the victims. But a judge’s sentence should match a judge’s words. In this case the killer deserved years behind bars, not months.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.