Thousands of Pennsylvanians and millions of Americans could lose the help they’re getting to buy health insurance if the Supreme Court takes a seven-word phrase in the 900-page Affordable Care Act out of context.

On March 4, the court will hear arguments in the case of King v. Burwell in which four plaintiffs claim that, because the law at one point says subsidies to help people buy coverage must be distributed “through an Exchange established by the State,” consumers in as many as 37 states should be excluded.

After the law was enacted in 2010, 13 states set up and now operate their own exchanges, seven others operate exchanges in partnership with the federal government and the rest — including Pennsylvania — defer to the federal health care exchange. In Pennsylvania, that means working people who earn too much for Medicaid and don’t get insurance through their employers can buy individual and family policies through HealthCare.gov.

As of mid-February, 472,000 state residents had done so — 78,840 in the Pittsburgh region. Nine in 10 were eligible for subsidies that, according to the Pennsylvania Health Access Network, averaged $230 a month, with 69 percent of people paying less than $100 a month for coverage.

Advertise with us

Joseph Lucas, a 52-year-old house painter from the South Side, is an example, and he’s part of a Center for American Progress campaign that considers the lawsuit another political attack on Obamacare.

Mr. Lucas says that, when he was younger, he didn’t worry about health insurance. In his 40s, he started buying it, but the cost quickly overtook his ability to pay for it. Then, in 2010, he had an aortic aneurysm and afterward could no longer buy insurance at any cost because he had a dreaded pre-existing condition. Now, because of Obamacare, he pays $150 a month for coverage that is subsidized by $233 from the government, all through a federal exchange. This means he can afford his prescription drugs and an annual checkup with a cardiologist and CT scan.

For Mr. Lucas and millions like him, the debate over the meaning of those seven little words is not a semantic argument. It’s a matter of life and death.

Think about the narrow interpretation of Obamacare based on that one phrase, then compare it to the reason that Obamacare was established — to help all uninsured Americans, not just those who live in certain states, become eligible and pay for coverage.

In Pennsylvania, Gov. Tom Wolf has begun to explore options to help residents if the high court sides with the plaintiffs in King v. Burwell. Planning for the worst while hoping for the best is necessary, but it would be an American tragedy if the court decides to use seven little words to take away a benefit that already is helping millions of working families.

Meet the Editorial Board