Pittsburgh and its school district are getting a new mallet for playing their version of Whac-A-Mole.

In this variation on the arcade game, the devilish details that keep popping up are loopholes that corporations use to sidestep the city’s 4 percent deed transfer tax. Just as officials smack one method down, a new one crops up.

The tax is supposed to be charged when property changes hands, but lots of big deals in town have found ways to get around it.

The most notorious example occurred in 2011, when a New York real estate investment firm bought the U.S. Steel Tower. Sales then weren’t subject to the tax unless they involved at least 90 percent of the interest in a property. In that case, the real estate company bought 89 percent of the company that owned the office building, then waited three years to pick up the remaining 11 percent. The city, school district and the state, which split the tax proceeds, missed out on $10 million.

Advertise with us

Other firms took advantage of that loophole and another that dealt with holding companies, until the Legislature changed state law in 2012.

What seemed like “game over” wasn’t the end.

Last year, GMH Capital Partners found a way to significantly cut its deed transfer tax when it acquired the Cork Factory complex in the Strip District. That sale was structured between two related holding companies, which made it eligible for a different tax break.

Under the law, a sale between two related companies can be the equivalent of a sale between two family members. Because the supposition is that Mom won’t charge Sonny the full market value for the family homestead, for instance, the tax is based on the assessed value instead. The two related companies that bought the Cork Factory got a bargain because that property had been assessed at $19 million, far below its actual value.

With no foolproof way to make the full tax stick in every transfer, the school district and the Urban Redevelopment Authority have decided to play offense instead of defense.

Advertise with us

They’ll soon start requiring developers that accept tax incentives for their projects to agree in advance that, in any future sale, they won’t structure the deals in a way that avoids paying the transfer tax.

This smart new strategy gives taxing bodies the upper hand, no matter where the next exception to the rule pops up.

Meet the Editorial Board.