A runaway train is rolling through Harrisburg, but it will crash and burn in cities and towns across Pennsylvania.

Hospitals and large nonprofits are pushing for a state constitutional amendment that could end attempts by local government to force them to make payments to help cover municipal services. That would leave the average residents and businesses that pay property taxes on the hook, as they are today, for more than their fair share of the cost of policing, firefighting and road maintenance.

The amendment would do this by taking away from the courts the authority to define what constitutes a tax-exempt charity and giving it to lawmakers who are susceptible to lobbying by deep-pocketed, albeit nonprofit, institutions.

Senate Bill 4 contains the proposal, which must be passed in two consecutive sessions of the Legislature to become part of the state constitution. It was OK’d once by the General Assembly and is on a fast track for second approval. If that happens soon, the plan will go before Pennsylvania voters this year, perhaps as early as the May primary, for possible final adoption — all without much public exposure or extensive debate.

Advertise with us

Almost as a concession to the animosity rising against the Legislature’s hurry-up offense, the Senate Finance Committee has set a hearing for Wednesday on the bill. It comes, however, in the 11th hour of the amendment process — too late for a careful examination of this costly issue.

Yet the growing burdens posed by concentrations of tax-exempt property on communities and school districts that rely heavily on property tax income are for real. Pittsburgh, its school district and Allegheny County — as home to many medical facilities, colleges and universities — have a special stake in this.

Two years ago, the county’s Office of Property Assessment said that 39 percent of Pittsburgh’s real estate was tax-exempt — not contributing toward the upkeep of the city.

In December, state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale reported that all tax-exempt property in Allegheny County — including government-owned property, schools, worship sites, charitable groups, hospitals and higher education institutions — had a 2014 assessed value of $24.6 billion and a potential tax liability of $619.7 million. Medical facilities with “purely public charity” status alone accounted for $3.2 billion in property holdings and $76 million in potential property tax liability.

Imagine the relief that some or all of $76 million could provide the taxpayers of Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

A Post-Gazette review in 2012 said that health care giant UPMC was the county’s largest private property owner in terms of value — 656 acres worth $1.6 billion based on the 2002 assessment and 86 percent of it exempt from taxes. The University of Pittsburgh was second with $1 billion in property.

Communities certainly benefit from the jobs, economic activity and mission of such large enterprises — plus UPMC, for instance, has committed $100 million to the city’s Pittsburgh Promise scholarship program. But across Pennsylvania, in large cities and small towns, elected officials and average taxpayers alike believe big nonprofits still should pay some tangible amount toward the cost of police and fire protection, road repair, snow removal and public education.

No wonder Mayor Bill Peduto, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, the Pennsylvania Municipal League, Pennsylvania State Association of Boroughs, Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors, Pennsylvania Professional Firefighters Association and Pennsylvania Fraternal Order of Police oppose this misguided amendment.

The General Assembly must abandon this well-greased drive to change the constitution and instead focus on how to require rich nonprofits to contribute sensibly, fairly and uniformly toward public services. And at the proper steps in the process, Gov. Tom Wolf and the courts should be allowed to play their role.

But the forces behind this train wreck don’t want a solution and don’t want to involve judges they can’t control. For that reason, SB 4 is bad for Pennsylvania and should be scrapped by the Legislature.

Advertise with us

If that fails, the Post-Gazette and others will work to awaken the public to this scheme so they can bury it with their own votes.

Meet the Editorial Board.