If insanity, as the saying goes, is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result, the nation’s collective approach to mental health care is certifiable.
The latest example of a system that apparently failed to give sufficient help to a person who needed and sought care took place in Homestead on Friday, and the result was a massive fire that destroyed a historic section of the community.
Edward McDonald, 27, who lived in an apartment on East Eighth Avenue where the blaze began, is charged with arson and causing a catastrophe. He had called Homestead police days earlier, asking to speak to a member of UPMC’s re:solve Crisis Network, which provides round-the-clock, mental health crisis intervention. Medics took him for treatment, but it is unclear what was provided before he was sent home.
Unfortunately, the description of his condition that both he and his neighbors gave police after the fire — that he was hearing voices and having anxiety over what he believed was the impending end of the world — suggested McDonald needed more care. Instead, Homestead is dealing with more than $2 million in property damages and McDonald is being held in the Allegheny County Jail. The only good news is that no one was seriously injured, or worse, in the six-alarm fire.
We have heard such stories before, and anguished descriptions of efforts by relatives and friends to get treatment for their loved ones only to be stymied by bureaucratic hurdles intended to balance the privacy rights of an individual against society’s need to control dangerous, aberrant behavior.
There are no easy answers, but there is one comprehensive remedy on the table that deserves attention from Congress. U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, the Upper St. Clair Republican who also is a clinical psychologist, last year introduced the Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act. The bill died, but Mr. Murphy said at a news conference Tuesday that he will offer a similar plan this session to tackle the problem. At its core, the legislation would require changing how the nation pays for and provides mental health care.
On the local level, resources must be made available so that individuals with mental illnesses receive the medication, treatment and supervision they need. Or we could just wait around until another preventable tragedy strikes.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.