The city of Pittsburgh limits its residents to five pets, but New Sewickley Township in Beaver County has no such restrictions. This is why, in attempting to shut down Noreen and Rich Kohl’s large-dog rescue operation, town officials could not cite the 17 dogs in the yard, but instead labeled their home a commercial kennel.

This was not so much a distortion of facts as a lie.

A commercial operation exists to make money, but the Kohls’ venture is a registered nonprofit. If the couple is guilty of anything, it’s disturbing the peace. When dogs bark, neighbors tend to growl.

But neighbors also growl about leaf blowers at 7 a.m. and teenagers’ music late at night. Only in Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood does everyone get along. That’s why municipalities have zoning laws, which act as a cool arbiter when tempers blaze hot.

Advertise with us

It would be nice if, when troubled by the sounds and smells of an animal rescue, people would weigh the irritants against the good that they do. It’s clear from the Facebook page of Gentle Ben’s Giant Breed Dog Rescue that the Kohls provide a much-needed service, caring for dogs rejected by shelters because of their size until they find them permanent homes. Rescues have to go somewhere, and 2 acres is a reasonable space.

In a legal tussle lasting two years, New Sewickley officials said the Kohls had to comply with zoning laws governing kennels, which would have forced them to move or shut down. The Kohls, however, prevailed in two subsequent appeals, first in Common Pleas Court in December 2013 and again last week. The latest decision, in Commonwealth Court, was a triumph, not only for the big dogs but also for common sense.

It’s also a reminder to dwellers of the exurbs, where the uses of “semi–rural” property can turn neighbors into litigants, that it’s important to be familiar with property rights under local laws. Your right to have 20 dogs in your backyard, for one thing. Your right to move away from them, for another.

Meet the Editorial Board.