Cats were worshiped in ancient Egypt, and they’re still royalty on the Internet, where Grumpy Cat reigns.

But in animal shelters across the nation, more cats are euthanized than dogs, which is why two veterinarians — one in Florida, one in California — have launched the “Million Cat Challenge.” Their goal is to dramatically reduce the number of healthy cats euthanized in shelters, and ultimately to use euthanasia only to end suffering, not for population control. The motto of the initiative is “Every cat counts.”

While bird lovers and those allergic to cats might find that sentiment overwrought, if not horrific, we find the program’s goal impressive. One of its methods, however, is controversial: neutering and spaying feral cats and releasing them in their old neighborhoods. Known by the acronym TNR (Trap, Neuter, Release), the practice invites images of modern-day Rome, where an estimated 300,000 feral cats populate historic ruins, scavenging for food and biting the occasional tourist.

TNR proponents counter that most feral cats are healthy, just impossible to domesticate, and that releasing them where they were trapped is good not only for the cats but also for animal-shelter budgets. The city of Pittsburgh already provides free or low-cost sterilization for feral cats and provides traps for people to catch them. While under sedation, the cats’ left ears are cropped so they are easily identified as “community cats” (the euphemism for feral) and so they won’t be captured again.

Advertise with us

Homeless cats, however, are prone to fight, run into traffic and eat songbirds even when colonies of them are fed by volunteers. So some people might prefer other components of the Million Cat Challenge. They include urging shelters to provide help to owners so they can keep their cats instead of giving them to shelters and making adoptions easier and fees more affordable.

These seem the most palatable aspects of what we hope is a successful program. Meanwhile, when in Rome, stay clear of the cats.

Meet the Editorial Board.