Six decades ago, construction of the Civic Arena tore a hole in the heart of the Hill District. Now, neighborhood leaders are engaging in tactics that could imperil the community anew.

For more than two years, the Pittsburgh Penguins, elected officials and Hill District residents, business owners and organizations have been meeting to plan a future for the razed arena’s 28-acre site, which sits across the street from the team’s new home, Consol Energy Center.

In fits and starts, the talks progressed until September, when the parties settled on how to rebuild the community together. The agreement was signed by Marimba Milliones, president and CEO of the Hill Community Development Corp., Mayor Bill Peduto, city Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle, Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and Penguins chief operating officer Travis Williams. It set up an executive committee — with equal representation from the Hill, the team and government — to see that its provisions would be carried out.

The negotiated peace didn’t last long.

Advertise with us

In November, the Hill CDC asked the city planning commission, rather than the nine-member committee, to become the enforcer of the agreement. The commission said no, but weeks later it recommended legislation, proposed by Mr. Lavelle, that would raise the threshold for lower-priced housing units to 30 percent on any developments using public land or subsidies.

That figure had been a goal of Hill District representatives in the talks with the Penguins, but all the parties had signed off on 20 percent. It looked like the community was trying to renegotiate terms.

The CDC raised the stakes even higher this month, when it filed a formal appeal of the planning commission’s approval of the Penguins development plan. That blueprint is essential if the team is to move forward on the cleared land — including U.S. Steel’s plan to move its corporate headquarters to the site from space it now rents Downtown.

The Penguins’ development efforts will be stymied if every step forward meets bureaucratic and legal resistance. The sports franchise has demonstrated a willingness to work with the community all along, and it has kept its promises including subsidizing a grocery store and hiring a significant number of Hill residents and minorities for jobs at Consol and its adjacent restaurant and hotel.

It is indisputable that the Hill District suffered tremendous harm because of bad faith by city leaders 60 years ago. That doesn’t justify bad faith being shown now by neighborhood leaders, especially when the Penguins have shown that the team intends to keep its word.

Meet the Editorial Board.