The inspector general of the Department of Homeland Security issued a report card Tuesday on the effectiveness of the surveillance drone system on the U.S. southern border. It didn’t contain the kind of grades anyone would want to take home to the taxpayers.

U.S. Customs and Border Protection uses a fleet of 11 Predator B drones to spot undocumented individuals attempting to cross the border illegally from Mexico. But the inspector general’s audit said the 8-year-old program is poorly managed, ineffective and costs far more than expected. Only 2,200 of 120,939 people in 2013 who were nabbed sneaking illegally into the United States were caught with the help of drones.

Bad weather, frequent grounding for repairs and inadequate technological capacity conspired to prevent the surveillance drones from doing their jobs. Their cost of operation was underestimated, auditors reported, when it was learned that pilot salaries, equipment and overhead were left out of the calculation.

Operated from bases in Arizona and Texas, the Predator B system is such a disappointment that a $400 million proposal to expand its use must be rejected.

Advertise with us

The cost of using a piece of technology that has such a poor record is too high. Yet border security must be maintained and, according to the audit, the government would get much better results by spending its money on manned aircraft and ground surveillance.

Now that the surveillance drone audit has been released, it will be difficult for anyone in Washington to justify this boondoggle, particularly when Congress and the White House must find reasonable ways to reduce the federal budget.

Meet the Editorial Board